He warned us.
He said it would be a long podcast, and my God! He was right!
Gil Zilkha. I didn’t know him, never heard of him. He lured me in by the title: Essential Classical Music – The Best Opera Recordings. Apparently he knows me by proclivity.
I have a lot, I mean a lot, thousands of recordings. Mostly LP, some 78s, now many CDs, DVDs, not all of them opera.
I don’t have a lot of money, never did, so I bought what I could find cheap. Yard sales, thrift stores, remainders, record stores with overflow bins. “Not much call for classical music these days. Opera has a few fans, and once in a while he comes in, looks around, buys something that’s been sitting around for years just waiting for anybody.”
So, I thought, why not take a look at the blog? It might be interesting, and instructive, to hear what someone else has to say. Yes, I did learn things. Yes, I did have reservations.
The (almost) inexhaustive survey didn’t seem to be quite up to the more current minute of today or just before. Where was Jessye Norman? Where was more Kiri Te Kanawa? Young Jonas Kaufmann? Rene Fleming when is/she was, Cecilia Bartoli who still mostly is.
I did like the space he gave to Furtwangler. Ossie in Riverside knew him personally and held him in high contemporary esteem. Ossie said that Furtwangler’s Tchaikovsky’s Pathetique was the whole orchestra crying in the same one breath. I suspect that Ossie also knew Brahms, but I never asked.
I also like it that Gil, may I call him Gil? gave Flagstad some prominence. And that he spoke of Bjoerling in reverent tones.
I’m glad that he appreciated Ljuba Welitsch’s Salome with Reiner conducting. I think Gil doesn’t know about the earlier recording, where Ljuba, may I call her Ljuba? was the raw young teenager with the voice of desperate youth, Salome in person. Reiner’s performance with a better orchestra and better sound was with a more polished stronger-voiced Salome, but I find the earlier version more true to Strauss’ intention to startle the world with his presence as he burst upon the scene and shocked everybody with what he could do musically. (Gil said the opera was based on a novel by Oscar Wilde. Apparently he never saw or read the play.)
Gil’s post took me all day, with a brief break for food to keep my blood sugar up. I wasn’t watching the clock, but after about seven and a half hours, I postponed the rest. I still have to finish the last bit on Wagner. Wagner himself wrote marathons. Ossie said, “For Wagner, you need Sitzfleisch.”
Two of my take-aways from Gil’s Review are:
One, although he frequently apologized for it, was his inexplicable inability to pronounce some names and words, to misalign composers with their works, to correct himself incorrectly.
I looked him up because I wanted to hear him sing. He describes himself as a bass. I tracked down a recording of his performance of Schumann’s Dichterliebe, a wonderful song cycle I’d like to learn more completely myself. He has a pleasant voice, and I won’t categorize it here, except to say that, “Would I pay to hear him sing in public?” and the answer is, “Yes.”
The second take-away from his long long long podcast is that by the end his beard had grown out further and he needed a shave.

Discover more from Gary C. Sterling
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
